Selling

How to Ship Trading Cards in Canada Cheaply and Safely (2026 Guide)

Canada Post Lettermail prices, size limits and packing steps for raw cards, toploaders and graded slabs, so you can ship trading cards in Canada cheaply without losing cards or margin.

If you sell cards in Canada, shipping is often the part that eats your margin. A $6 card can't carry a $15 parcel, and a $600 card shouldn't go in a plain envelope with no tracking. The fix is to match the shipping method to the card's value, and to pack every card so it shows up the way it left. This guide walks through the Canada Post options sellers actually use, the size rules that decide which price you pay, and a simple packing routine for raw cards, toploaders and graded slabs.

All prices below are Canada Post's published consumer prices, checked on November 16, 2026. Rates change, so confirm them on Canada Post's site before you set your shipping charges.

Step 1: Know the three price tiers that matter

For most card sellers, nearly every shipment falls into one of three buckets.

Standard Lettermail (up to 50 g). This is a regular letter. Canada Post's Lettermail pricing page lists $1.44 for a single stamp or $1.24 per stamp bought in a booklet, coil or pane, for 0 to 30 g, and $1.75 for over 30 g up to 50 g. The catch is the size: Canada Post's size requirements cap a standard letter at 245 x 156 mm and 5 mm thick. A card in a penny sleeve between two pieces of cardboard can fit. A card in a toploader usually pushes past 5 mm once it's wrapped.

Non-standard and oversize Lettermail (up to 500 g). This is where most toploader shipments land. The maximum size is 380 x 270 mm and 20 mm thick, and the price starts at $2.61 for up to 100 g, with higher tiers up to $7.36 for 400 to 500 g. A single toploader in a small bubble mailer is normally well under 100 g, so one card, or a small stack, can ship for $2.61.

Tracked services. Lettermail has no tracking and no insurance. For anything you can't afford to lose, add tracking. Canada Post's Registered Mail add-on for domestic Lettermail was set at $13.15 plus postage from January 13, 2025, according to the Canada Gazette regulation that set the current stamp prices. Parcel services with tracking are priced by weight, size and distance, so use Canada Post's rate tools for a quote.

One more rule worth knowing: every piece of mail must be at least 140 x 90 mm. If you fold a bubble mailer down tight around a toploader, you can end up under the minimum. Use a mailer that is already the right size instead.

Step 2: Match the method to the card's value

There is no single right answer, but a simple rule of thumb keeps most sellers out of trouble:

  • Low-value singles and commons: standard or non-standard Lettermail. The postage is a dollar or two, and if one goes missing, the loss is small.
  • Mid-value cards: non-standard Lettermail is still common, but think about whether you could absorb a "never arrived" claim. If not, offer tracking.
  • High-value raw cards and graded slabs: always tracked, and ideally with coverage. Once a slab is bubble-wrapped in a rigid box, it is usually past Lettermail's 20 mm limit, so it goes as a parcel anyway.

The biggest hidden cost of untracked mail isn't the stamp. It's the dispute. With no tracking number you can't prove delivery, so if a buyer says a card never came, you usually have nothing to show. Sellers on community forums such as the eBay Canada community and Elite Fourum say the same thing: Lettermail is fine for cheap cards, and risky for anything that matters.

Step 3: Pack raw cards and toploaders properly

A good packing routine costs a few cents per order and saves you most of your damage claims.

  1. Sleeve the card. Put it in a soft penny sleeve first so the surface never touches hard plastic.
  2. Add a toploader or card saver. A toploader is the usual choice for raw cards. Seal the opening with a strip of painter's tape or a team bag so the card can't slide out. Avoid regular tape directly on the toploader opening; it can be hard to remove without damaging the card.
  3. Stop it from moving. Tape the toploader to a piece of thin cardboard, or sandwich it between two pieces, so it can't shift or bend inside the envelope. This also helps a non-standard letter stay flat.
  4. Use a bubble mailer that already fits. Pick a size that leaves the card snug without folding, and stays above the 140 x 90 mm minimum and below 20 mm thick.
  5. Weigh and measure before you stamp. A cheap kitchen scale and a ruler tell you which tier you're in. Being 1 mm over a limit is how a $1.24 letter becomes a $2.61 one, or a Lettermail item becomes a parcel.
  6. Write the address clearly and include a return address on every piece.

Some sellers report that a stiff or lumpy envelope can get pushed to a parcel at the counter, returned, or charged as short-paid postage. Keeping the package flat, even and within the size limits is the best way to avoid that.

Step 4: Ship graded slabs and high-value cards

Slabs are tough, but they crack, and the label can scratch. Treat them like the expensive items they are.

  1. Bag the slab in a soft sleeve or slab bag to protect it from scratches.
  2. Wrap it in bubble wrap so it can't touch the walls of the box.
  3. Use a small rigid box, not an envelope, with packing material filling the gaps. When you shake it, nothing should move.
  4. Ship tracked. Choose a service with tracking, and add coverage that matches the card's value if the service offers it.
  5. Take photos of the card, the packing and the sealed box before it leaves. If anything goes wrong, those photos are your evidence.

If you're shipping a card to be graded or stored, the same rules apply: Canada Post's tracked and insured services, rigid protection, and photos.

Step 5: Charge shipping fairly and keep your margin

Shipping is a cost of doing business, so set it up so it doesn't come out of your pocket:

  • Offer two options where you can: a cheap untracked option for low-value cards and a tracked option for anything more. Let the buyer choose.
  • Combine orders. One envelope with five cards costs far less than five envelopes. Encourage buyers to shop several cards at once.
  • Buy stamps in booklets if you ship a lot of standard letters, since the booklet price for up to 30 g is lower than a single stamp.
  • Check how your marketplace treats shipping fees. Some platforms take a percentage of the shipping you charge as well as the item price. On The Collectibles Exchange, commission is calculated on the item price only, and shipping is never commissioned. Buyers pick from the shipping options a seller offers, including tracked services or untracked Lettermail, and pay for it at checkout. A buyer who picks untracked Lettermail accepts that it has no tracking or insurance.

Shipping to the United States

Many Canadian sellers also ship to the US. Cross-border mail has its own prices and rules, separate from the domestic prices above. If you sell to American buyers, check Canada Post's US and international prices before you list, and lean towards a tracked service for anything of real value.

FAQ

What is the cheapest way to ship one trading card in Canada?

A single card in a penny sleeve, protected with cardboard and kept under 5 mm thick, can go as standard Lettermail: $1.24 with a booklet stamp or $1.44 with a single stamp for up to 30 g. A card in a toploader usually needs non-standard Lettermail, which starts at $2.61 for up to 100 g.

Can I ship a toploader by Lettermail?

Many sellers do, as non-standard Lettermail, as long as the envelope stays within 380 x 270 mm and 20 mm thick, and weighs 500 g or less. Keep it flat and well-supported so it doesn't feel like a lumpy parcel.

Does Lettermail have tracking?

No. Lettermail has no tracking and no insurance. If you need proof of delivery, add Registered Mail or use a tracked parcel service.

How should I ship a PSA or other graded card?

In a slab bag, wrapped in bubble wrap, inside a small rigid box, with tracking. A slab packed that way is usually too thick for Lettermail anyway.

How do I avoid "item not received" claims?

Use tracking on anything you couldn't afford to refund, photograph your packing, write addresses clearly, and keep receipts. For cheap cards, accept that untracked mail carries a small risk and price it in.

Sell your cards on a Canadian marketplace

The Collectibles Exchange is a Canadian marketplace for sports cards and Pokémon. There are no listing or monthly fees: sellers pay one commission when a card sells, from 12% under $50 down to 9% at $1,000 and above, and shipping is never commissioned. You can browse the marketplace or see the shop storefronts. Card shops can open a free business account with their own storefront at thecollectiblesexchange.com/card-shops, and collectors can sign up and start listing from the same page.

shippingcanada postlettermailsellingtoploadersgraded cardscard shops

Keep reading

More articles →